Chaga Warnings: Oxalates & Side Effects from Inonotus obliquus

by Garrett Kopp May 12, 2021 8 Comments

Chaga Warnings: Oxalates & Side Effects from Inonotus obliquus

As we have discussed in previous blogs, Chaga is well known for its medical value and potent bioavailable compounds. There are many such compounds that have been isolated, identified, and described by scientists. Often promoted for its ability to combat a variety of ailments, it is easy to overlook potential side effects from overuse of Chaga.

In this blog we will identify the known (potentially negative) side effects of overusing Chaga & the compounds responsible: oxalates. We will also describe ways one could mitigate these potential issues as well as offering our best attempt to quantify & define what overuse of Chaga products might look like.

 

What are Oxalates?

Oxalates are naturally occurring compounds found in plants and some fungi. They are common in many foods, occuring in everything from avocados to raspberries, and even chocolate. Certain foods such as spinach, almonds, and beet greens are especially high in oxalates. There are two categories of oxalates in terms of nutritional and digestive health: soluble and insoluble.

The insoluble oxalates (such as calcium oxalate, magnesium oxalate, and iron oxalate) are not absorbed in the digestive system and pass harmlessly. On the other hand, soluble oxalates (such as potassium oxalate and sodium oxalate), release free oxalate anions which pass into the bloodstream.

The body naturally neutralizes & rids itself of soluble oxalates, but in high amounts, soluble oxalates can overwhelm the body's ability to do so in a timely manner, which could result in serious negative side effects.

In the bloodstream, free oxalate may bind with free calcium to produce calcium oxalate crystals. Over time, excessive presence of these crystals could lead to kidney stones, gout, and/or physical damage to the kidneys, while simultaneously depleting essential calcium needed for healthy growth.

 

External Research on Oxalates in Chaga

Chaga is considered to have relatively high oxalate content according to several sources. There exists at least one case in which someone who routinely consumed large amounts of powdered Chaga suffered kidney damage, and ultimately died.

    1. A 72-year-old Japanese female who had been diagnosed with liver cancer began to ingest Chaga mushroom powder (4 - 5 teaspoons per day) and died 6 months later from kidney failure (1).

    2. The British Columbia Center for Disease Control states that the dosage of dried material for Inonotus obliquus should net exceed 3.6 grams of dried material per day (2).

While this offers a good baseline for theoretical consumption, we explicitly discourage the consumption of ground Chaga. You can derive the same benefits as well as mitigate the risk of harmful concentrations of oxalates by choosing Chaga tea or Chaga tincture instead.

 

Internal Research on Oxalates in Chaga

In 2020 we conducted internal testing on this subject at our small in-house lab. Based on a report produced by our lead Chemist (Maya Duncan-White), we determined that our samples of aqueous Chaga extract (aka Chaga tea) contained 800mg soluble oxalates per 100g of dried material.

That is, if one were to brew 100g (just shy of 4oz) of ground chaga for 30 minutes at 80C, they could expect the hot water extract to contain approximately 800mg of soluble oxalates. This equates roughly to the same amount of soluble oxalates one could expect to ingest from eating a half cup of spinach (100 grams of spinach contains approximately 750mg of soluble oxalates).

In each Birch Boys tea bag, there are only 2 grams of ground Chaga, so one tea bag (steeped at 80C for 30 minutes) would contain approximately 16 mg of soluble oxalates. An interesting paradigm is the fact that wild Chaga contains elevated levels of calcium, magnesium, iron, and other minerals.

Although soluble oxalates can chelate these from the body, tea brewed from wild Chaga could simultaneously replenish these minerals to some degree. It’s also worth noting that this chelation action may even act beneficially in certain instances; removing hazardous heavy metals such as mercury and lead from the body.

 

Concluding Thoughts

Those prone to kidney stones, as well as those diagnosed with kidney disease and/or osteoporosis may be best advised to avoid Chaga all together, and should certainly consult with a licensed physician before using Chaga products. Otherwise, in healthy moderation, oxalates in Chaga do not seem to pose any serious health threats to the average person. The risks posed by oxalates in Chaga can be considered negligible if used intelligently by healthy individuals.

Proper research is critical in your selection of a quality Chaga product, extract, or supplement. We urge to be aware that much of the mainstream mushroom market consists of dissolvable mushroom extract powders that come from China - without transparency or regard to the alteration methods used to transform the biochemical composition of said mushrooms. We also urge consumers to be wary of consuming Chaga products in a solid powder state, as one might do with edible mushrooms such as Lion’s Mane or Maitake. Chaga is not an “edible” mushroom, in this sense.

There are various products marketed as “Chaga” by people who may not even understand the composition of the Chaga products they are promoting / selling. In a newly-emerging industry fraught with profit-driven brands who view the responsibility of disclosure as an unnecessary burden, due diligence is left to none other than you: the consumer.

We hope that this blog has helped put your Chaga concerns into a more accurate & informed perspective. If you learned something, join the discussion by commenting below, and feel free to use the one time coupon code: OXALATES to save 15% on any purchase of any Birch Boys product(s).

 

References

    1. Kikuchi Y, Seta K, Ogawa Y, Takayama T, Nagata M, Taguchi T, Yahata K. Chaga mushroom-induced oxalate nephropathy. Clin Nephrol. 2014 Jun;81(6):440-4. doi: 10.5414/CN107655. PMID: 23149251.

    2. B. (2018, July 1). Risk assessment of chaga mushroom tea. Retrieved May 6, 2021, from http://www.bccdc.ca/resource-gallery/Documents/Educational%20Materials/EH/FPS/Food/Risk_Assessment_of_Chaga_Mushroom_Tea.pdf

    3. Shashkina MY, Shashkin PN, Sergeev AV. Chemical and medicobiological properties of chaga. Pharm Chem J. 2006;40(10):560–568. [review] [Google Scholar]

    4. Savage GP, Nilzen V, Osterberg K, Vanhanen L. Soluble and insoluble oxalate content of mushrooms. Int J Food Sci Nutr. 2002 Jul;53(4):293-6. doi: 10.1080/09637480120057000. PMID: 12090024.




Garrett Kopp
Garrett Kopp

Author


8 Responses

Dee
Dee

June 19, 2021

This is true but Magnesium should cancel all this out. Without the presence of magnesium you can form the kidney stones. Magnesium binds to the oxilate.

Dee
Dee

June 19, 2021

This is true but Magnesium should cancel all this out. Without the presence of magnesium you can form the kidney stones. Magnesium binds to the oxilate.

Kristy Sullivan
Kristy Sullivan

May 13, 2021

We had heard years ago, when my husband’s mom had cancer, that is was great for helping that—some local people here in Lewis County have used it as part of their regimen and been successful. While we were learning more about it, I could have sworn it was stated somewhere that it helped WITH kidney stones! So my husband who suffers from the calcium oxalate form has been drinking just one cup of tea every morning… usually from a local lump. Would anyone have a good idea of what I can replace this with? a new tea that is helpful for stones? There are so many other benefits to it, I hate to have him give it up, especially with the knuckle of ginger and cinnamon stick I add to the brew. I do make a homemade organic lemonade with stevia that he has everyday to help with stones… but now I’m thinking the two drinks may just cancel each other out!

Jean
Jean

May 12, 2021

Hi. I brew a large pot with 2-3 chunks of chaga – maybe once a month. I then drink it over several days. Is there any way to determine how much oxalate I’m ingesting?

Kathleen
Kathleen

May 12, 2021

What about Birch Boys Chaga tincture? I squirt a dropper full (along with Turkey Tail and Reishe) in my kombucha every evening. Should I be concerned about the cumulative affect, especially since I also eat spinach and beets regularly?

Marie
Marie

May 12, 2021

Aside from the oxalates concerns, what are the concerns with powdered mushrooms?

Eric Kiernan
Eric Kiernan

May 12, 2021

Garrett,

It was great speaking with you today and I appreciate the personal phone call to address my question. I will definitely be giving you a call as soon as I know that I will be up in the area which should be around the end of June. I have lots of thoughts that I’d like to share with you.

Keep doing what you’re doing and all the best to you and your business.

Sincerely, Eric Kiernan

Anne Munn
Anne Munn

May 12, 2021

I would like to know is Chaga safe if you use 1&1/2 a dropper full a day?
I take lions mane twice a day. Is that too much?

Leave a comment


Also in Blog

Comparing the Benefits of Chaga Tea to Chaga Tincture. Which is best?
Comparing the Benefits of Chaga Tea to Chaga Tincture. Which is best?

by Brian Baumer April 03, 2021 7 Comments

Throughout this blog, we will compare the water soluble components of Chaga (aka - tea) with the ethanol soluble components (aka - tincture) in order to characterize the benefits of each & help you make more informed Chaga choices.

Continue Reading

10 Ways We've Grown from 2020
10 Ways We've Grown from 2020

by Garrett Kopp December 30, 2020 7 Comments

When I think about everything that has happened in the past 12 months, it’s truly unbelievable. Despite how unfortunate, depressing, and infuriating this year has been for myself and so many others, I can’t ignore that 2020 was also the single most important year for the success of this company and its future. Here are 10 ways that Birch Boys, Inc. has grown from this difficult year.

Continue Reading

Comparing medicinal mushrooms
Comparing Functional Fungi for Healing Benefits

by Garrett Kopp September 24, 2020 2 Comments

While it is true that each mushroom differs in its specific composition of mycochemicals, most offer shared health benefits...

Continue Reading